Every year, tens of thousands of Americans who volunteer to defend this country face a threat they never anticipated — not from a foreign enemy, but from within their own ranks. And under current law, most of them have almost no legal recourse when it happens.
The Pentagon estimates that approximately 20,000 active-duty service members were sexually assaulted in a single recent year, out of a total force of 1.3 million. Researchers at Brown University’s Costs of War project found that between 2001 and 2023, 24% of active-duty women and nearly 2% of active-duty men were sexually assaulted during their service. The true number is likely even higher, since many victims never come forward.
What makes this crisis even more troubling is a legal barrier that most Americans have never heard of — one that effectively strips military sexual assault survivors of the right to sue their attackers in civil court.
A Legal Doctrine That Protects Perpetrators
The barrier is known as the Feres Doctrine, a rule that traces back to a 1950 Supreme Court decision. The doctrine blocks service members from suing the government for injuries that arise out of or are “incident to service.” Courts have interpreted those words broadly — covering not just combat injuries, but also medical malpractice at military hospitals, negligence by civilian federal employees, and even a secret government experiment in which service members were administered LSD without their knowledge or consent.
Courts have ruled the same about sexual assault — that rape can qualify as something that happens “incident to service,” effectively placing it in the same legal category as a battlefield wound. That interpretation means survivors of military sexual assault generally cannot pursue civil damages against their assailants or the officials who enabled them.
The doctrine is typically justified as a way to protect military discipline and effectiveness — the idea being that commanders should not face lawsuits for decisions made in combat or training. But critics argue the rule has expanded far beyond that original purpose.
Exceptions do exist, though they are narrow. In one recent high-profile decision, a California appeals court allowed a U.S. Army officer to proceed with a civil lawsuit following an alleged assault by a fellow service member — but only because the incident occurred at a hotel rather than on a military base. Critics say that outcome highlights how arbitrary the system has become, with accountability hinging on geography rather than the nature of the act itself.
A Long Pattern of Scandals and Incremental Fixes
Sexual assault in the military is not a new problem. High-profile episodes have surfaced repeatedly over the decades — from the Tailhook scandal to Aberdeen Proving Ground to cases involving dozens of trainees assaulted by instructors at Lackland Air Force Base. The murder of Army Specialist Vanessa Guillén at Fort Hood brought renewed national attention to the issue. An independent investigation following that killing described a “permissive environment” for sexual assault and sexual harassment at the installation — nearly three decades after military leaders first pledged to eliminate sexual violence from the ranks.
Each scandal has prompted a response. The Pentagon has launched new hotlines, updated procedures for prosecuting sex crimes, and introduced new data collection systems. Each time, the assaults have continued.
Legislation That Could Change the Rules
A bill currently before Congress aims to close the legal gap. The Military Sexual Trauma Accountability Act, pending before the Senate Judiciary Committee, would allow service members who experience sexual assault, sexual harassment, or related misconduct such as revenge porn to pursue civil damages — the same legal remedy available to any civilian survivor.
Supporters of the bill argue that the current system creates the wrong incentives. Without the possibility of civil liability, there is less pressure on military institutions to take prevention seriously. Accountability through the courts, they contend, could push leaders to do more.
Proponents also frame the issue in terms of military readiness. Sexual assault drives trained personnel out of the service at a time when military recruitment is already under strain. Impunity, they argue, undermines military discipline — the very thing the Feres Doctrine was originally designed to protect.
Not everyone in the current administration appears aligned with that view. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has moved to chip away at some of the accountability and oversight measures put in place by prior administrations.
Lawmakers pushing for passage say the lame-duck session presents a window of opportunity. Without upcoming election pressures, members of Congress have more flexibility to act on issues that may be politically complicated but are grounded in straightforward questions of fairness — whether the men and women who serve this country deserve the same legal protections that every other American already has. Follow Military Times for continued coverage of this issue.










Comments are closed.